Showing posts with label 2010 Presidential Election. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2010 Presidential Election. Show all posts

November 7, 2012

Admin Resource

Administrative resource or admin resource is what Ukrainians say when they refer to government's abuse of power. I had a blog post about how the Yanukovych administration rigged the 2012 parliamentary elections using their admin resource to affect election results in hospitals, prisons, armies, public schools, and the rest of the public sector. Now I can show cool data from NGO Maidan. The following charts show that public support of the Party of Regions and voter turnouts are shooting through the roof at the special polling stations like hospitals and prisons. Basically, if you don't know how it's done, you must see that mainly sick people and prisoners support the Party of Regions.

http://world.maidan.org.ua/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SpecialPS.jpg

October 31, 2012

Big Family Election

Here are pretty cool observations from one of my friends about the 2012 Parliamentary Elections (ht Diana Cucos):
FYI: MP - member of parliament

MP of the Party of Regions (presidential party):

Viktor Yanukovych Jr. is MP. He is one of two sons of President Viktor Yanukovych (the Party of Regions). Viktor Yanukovych Sr. is a dentist who has recently joined the Forbes list of the 100 wealthiest people of Ukraine. How many fillings and crowns does it take to become a millionaire? Kids, you should become dentists.

Alexei Azarov is MP. His father is the Prime Minister Nikolay Azarov.

Peter Melnik is MP. He is the president of the Tax Administration University. Prime Minister Azarov is the god-father of Melnik's kid.

Viktor Baloga is MP. He is the director of the State Emergency Management Agency.

Baloga Jr. and Baloga Sr. who are Mr. Baloga's brothers are also MP. So all three brothers are MPs.

Andrei Kluev and his brother Sergei Kluev are MPs. Andrei Kluev is the Secretary of the Security Council.

Artem Pshonka is MP. He is the son of Viktor Pshonka who is the General Attorney of Ukraine.

Julia Levochkin is MP. Her brother is Sergei Levochkin who is the Director of the Yanukovych Admnistration.

Dobkin Jr. is MP. His brother is the odious governor of the Kharkiv province, Dmitry Dobkin. Until recently Dobkin Jr. has been admitted to the drug rehabilitation center in Switzerland.

Artem Semenyuk is MP. His father is the governor of the Chernovtsy province, Michael Papiev. The change of the last name was a cheap trick.

And this list goes on. I am just tired of translating the big family of the Party of Regions.

October 20, 2012

Sick Leave Voting

I just got off the phone (actually, Skype) with my friends from Ukraine. Of course, we talked about upcoming parliamentary election. Things are getting worse every day. The pro-presidential Party of Regions just pulled another ace out of their bottomless sleeve - the sick-leave voting. Illiberal democracies watch and learn how it's done in Ukraine.

What is the sick-leave voting? All employees of public sector are forced to vote for the Party of Regions. School teachers, university professors, students, army generals, soldiers, police officers, firemen, prison guards, prisoners, doctors, and even their patients are forced to vote for the pro-presidential Party of Regions. Voting in public hospitals is a case in point. Like military base or prison, hospitals fall in a category of separate electoral district in Ukraine. To win elections in the special electoral districts, the Yanukovych administration forces doctors, nurses, and other hospital employees to take a sick leave and check in their own hospital for the upcoming election. Moreover, doctors, nurses, and other hospital employees have to check in at least two friends or patients to their hospital so that all they together can vote for the Party of Regions as one big happy family. Of course, you can refuse to do that for a very tiny cost of losing your job. That's how it's also done in the army, the police force, the schools, and everywhere else in the public sector in Ukraine.  

The Party of Regions is so power hungry that they don't stop at anything. I have already written that all TV cable companies dropped TVi that was the only independent TV channel in Ukraine. TVi was the last bastion of mass media representation that the opposition politicians could count on for the parliamentary elections. The Party of Regions proudly checked the mass media control off their election prep list. I am still amazed or dazed by how political situation has made a 180-degree turn since 2010. Less than two years ago Ukraine was a troublesome emerging democracy. Now Ukraine is a solid consolidating autocracy.

The Party of Regions or the Regionnaires (ht Alexander Motyl) were unstoppable on their way to exterminate any meaningful political opposition. The Party of Regions threw dozens of opposition politicians and businessmen to jails without any proper judicial procedures. Those opposition politicians, businessmen, and journalists who saw "the writing on the wall" fled Ukraine. The political opposition is meaningless now. It takes at least three powerful men to replace a woman. Yatsenyuk (Tymoshenko's replacement), Klitschko (yes, the heavy-weight boxing champ of the world), and former President of Ukraine, Mr. Yushchenko cannot still get their act together while the elections will be next Sunday.

Ukraine has one week left before the nation will completely fall off the political map of world democracies. Most of my friends are just sick of this situation. They are sick to their stomachs because they cannot change anything and because there is no demand for this change from the political opposition. My friends who happen to work in public sector like hospital or school are also sick to their stomachs because they are losing their freedom. They cannot vote for the opposition politician and keep their job at the same time. Neither they can vote for the odious Party of Regions and keep their dignity intact. Human dignity or job - that's a trade-off for many Ukrainians at the upcoming parliamentary elections. If human dignity paid your bills, the choice would be fair.

July 13, 2010

Ukraine’s Fiscal Policy Hurts National Exporters

Ukraine's fiscal policy forces the national exporters to a bankruptcy. A large number of export-oriented companies complain that the state refused to issue VAT (value-added tax) refunds because of exponentially increasing foreign and national debts. In Ukraine the Commerce Code and the Tax Code clearly state that the exporting companies should receive VAT refunds to avoid a double taxation because their products are subject to VAT in the importing countries. The state, however, issues tax refunds only to few companies that supported President Yanukovich in the 2010 Presidential elections. Other companies have to pay a high price for their political views. One of the largest steel-exporters, Arcelor Mittal, plans to lay off thousands of workers if the company does not receive VAT refund in the amount of $312 million (2.5 billion UAH). A transnational agro-producing corporation, Cargill, left the Ukrainian grain market because the government refused to reimburse VAT in the amount of $100 million (800 million UAH). Other exporters also face potential downsizing if the state defaults on VAT liabilities.

February 8, 2010

Stealing Popcorn

Today HQ of Mr. Viktor Yanukovich's presidential campaign showed Stealing Popcorn that was originally presented in LA more than a month ago. I've not seen it yet. But it seems that the movie represents a mix of documentary and fiction. It's about corruption in Ukraine, the Lazarenko case, and Mrs. Yulia Tymoshenko who is allegedly associated with Mr. Lazarenko's embezzlement. Btw, Stealing Popcorn features a well-known Columbia University's Professor of Post-Soviet Foreign Policy Tymothy Frye, Ukrainian-born Emeritus Professor of Economics at University of California - Berkeley, John Letiche, and UCLA's Associate Professor of Political Science Richard Anderson.

Mr. Pavel Lazarenko was Ukraine's PM between 1996 and 1997. He was accused of fraud and embezzlement of $200 million. He escaped Ukrainian justice by flying to USA where he was arrested and convicted by the American justice system. Mr Lazarenko was sentenced to nine years in federal prison. In 2004 Mr. Lazarenko posted $86 million bail to remain under house arrest at an undisclosed location in California. The Transparency International named Mr. Lazarenko the eighth most corrupt political leader in recent history.


February 7, 2010

Mr. Viktor Yanukovich Won the 2010 Presidential Election

According to all exit-polls, former PM Viktor Yanukovich defeated the incumbent PM Yulia Tymoshenko in the 2nd round of the 2010 Presidential election.

Here is a link to all exit-polls.


Ukraine's Central Election Committee (CVK) counted 99% of votes. Former PM Viktor Yanukovich received 48.69% of votes and the incumbent PM Yulia Tymoshenko received 45.73% of votes. Though Mr. Yanukovich's lead over Mrs. Tymoshenko dropped from 10% to 3%, Mrs. Tymoshenko still lost the 2010 Presidential election.

Here is a link to a map that shows a distribution of votes across provinces. An ideological difference between Eastern and Western Ukraine seems to persist.

February 5, 2010

Is the 2010 Presidential Election a Repeat of the 2007 Parliamentary Election?

Dear readers,
How many difference can you find between the results of the 2007 Parliamentary election and the 1st round of the 2010 Presidential election?

From UkraineWatch

From UkraineWatch

The 2010 Presidential Election in Ukraine: It’s a Final Countdown


I really love this 80's rock song. Yeah, it's the final countdown for the 2010 Presidential Election in Ukraine. This Sunday Ukrainian voters will chose their next president. Will it be an odious former PM Viktor Yanukovich who was officially backed by the Kremlin in 2004 and tarnished his political reputation by using his de jure political power to rig the 2004 presidential election? Btw, the law suit against Mr. Yanukovich never made it to the Supreme Courte. Will it be another nevertheless odious incumbent PM Yulia Tymoshenko who drove Ukraine's economy to the brink of collapse by using command-control approach and choking individual economic freedom? Btw, the Kremlin considers Mrs. Tymoshenko the second BFF (after Mr. Yanukovich) since she can take all credits for the recent gas deal between Russia's state-owned Gazprom and Ukraine. According to the newly signed gas contract, among all European countries, Ukraine will pay the highest price for the Russian gas.
From UkraineWatch

Anyways, whoever wins this election should make it in a true democratic process! Nobody wants to repeat the Orange Revolution. Moreover, Ukrainians are not really psyched about the upcoming 2nd round because very few voters can tell a difference between candidate Y and candidate T. Honestly, what's the difference? Mr. Yanukovich never disguised his pro-Russian political and economic preferences. PM Yulia Tymoshenko's economic policy did not leave much of a choice for Ukrainian business. At the present moment, Ukraine has the largest number of international trade restrictions. Russia does not really care about it because the Kremlin still apathetically negotiates its WTO membership. I am surprised that the WTO has not addressed the Ukrainian situation yet. Well, it's understandable because the Sino-US trade war is much more fun to watch. Plus, the global economic crisis is not over yet. And some countries kind of overreacted with their own trade policies. All this together keeps WTO busy.
Honestly, the previous presidential elections were much more interesting because there was always something at stake (see figures below). The 1991 presidential election was important in terms of state-building. The newly independent state needed a democratic leader such as Mr. Leonid Kravchuk (1991-1994). However, the incumbent president Kravchuk catered more to the nationalist constituency in the Western Ukraine so that the 1994 presidential election allowed the Eastern Ukraine to bring pro-Russian technocrat, Mr. Leonid Kuchma, to the power.
From UkraineWatch

The 1994 presidential election played a seminal role in the emergence of the region-based division among Ukrainian voters. In 1994 it became clear that the Western provinces held a strong preference for nationalist pro-Western politics, while the Eastern and Southern provinces strongly supported technocratic pro-Russian politics. Another interesting observation was that the Central provinces turned out to become the potential swing constituencies.
The 1999 presidential election also spiced up the Ukrainian politics. That year the Ukrainian voters had to make a crucial choice between two antagonistically ideological candidates: a left-wing pro-Russian Mr. Petro Symonenko, a leader of the Communist Party, and a right-wing incumbent president Kuchma (1994-2004) who learned to balance out his foreign policy between both EU and Russia. The leader of the Communist Party failed to capitalize on nostalgic political preferences of the Soviet-generation constituency. By receiving only 37.8% of votes, Mr. Symonenko succeeded in swinging only several Central and couple Southern provinces. In the meanwhile, most of the former Kravchuk constituency located in the Western provinces and the stronghold pro-Kuchma constituency in the Eastern provinces came united against the ghost of the communism. Since then the left-wing politicians witnessed a tremendous drop in their popularity. The communist front-runner Petro Symonenko received only 4.97% and 3.54% of votes in the 2004 and 2010 presidential elections, correspondingly.
Then Ukraine had the Orange Revolution in 2004. The 2004 presidential election will always be a historical landmark of Ukraine's state-building. After all calamities surrounding rigged 2nd round and its rerun in the late December, a nationalist liberal pro-Western candidate and former PM Viktor Yuschchenko won the election with 51.99% of votes. Once again the same swing Central provinces gave Mr. Yushchenko so needed handicap. The incumbent PM Viktor Yanukovich lost not only election but also his PM position. Furthermore, the authoritarian glitch in the Kuchma administration tarnished former PM's political reputation significantly. While Mr. Yanukovich received 44.25% of votes in 2004, his popularity dropped to 35.3% votes in the 1st round of the 2010 presidential election. Nonetheless, Mr. Yanukovich received a ten-percent lead over the incumbent PM Tymoshenko. The incumbent president Yushchenko (2005-2010) who became ultra-nationalist closer to the end of his term received only 5.45% of votes. It's actually very interesting fact about the 2010 presidential election that for the first time in the recent political history of Ukraine the incumbent president did not make it to the 2nd round. On the other hand, the 2nd round offers Ukrainian voters a cliché choice between two PMs: the former and the incumbent. Once again, what's the difference?
From UkraineWatch

Nonetheless, I am sure that the final results of the 2010 presidential election will give us more fodder for further discussion of Ukraine's political institutional development. The key to a victory in the 2nd round of this presidential election is a candidate's ability to capitalize on constituencies in the swing Central and Southern provinces. But I guess it's too late to give this piece of advice, ha!
From UkraineWatch

From UkraineWatch

February 4, 2010

Assorted Links

  1. Reuters writes that "Ukraine's Yulia Tymoshenko vowed on Thursday to call people onto the streets in a second "Orange Revolution" even fiercer than that of 2004, if rival Viktor Yanukovich tried to rig Sunday's vote for president". What can I say? First, it's not the first time when the incumbent PM Tymoshenko uses a scare-everyone-to-hell strategy (e.g. the Swine Flu outbreak). Second, how can Mr. Yanukovich rig votes if he does not have the so-called adminresource. In other words, you can't rig votes if you are not in power.
  2. The Christian Science Monitor's Fred Weir writes that "Ukraine votes Feb. 7 in a runoff between bitter rivals Yulia Tymoshenko and Viktor Yanukovych that some say could destabilize the democratic process". Several economists such as Dr. Acemoglu, Dr. Johnson, and Dr. Robinson (AJR) would agree that a status quo change in de jure distribution of political power would cause a status quo change in de facto distribution of political and economic power. So far Ukraine's post-socialist political and economic development shows that de facto institutions cause a change in de jure institutions.
  3. Finally, here is much more interesting piece of news. The BusinessWeek's Halia Pavliva writes that "Ukraine will seek to borrow $500 million to $1 billion by selling Eurobonds as early as next quarter, Economy Minister Bohdan Danylyshyn said, as Europe's hardest hit economy looks for ways to restructure its debt". That's a great point because Ukraine's current debt is a serious economic problem. But I would respectfully disagree that Ukraine is Europe's hardest hit economy. What about the Baltic trinity? Well, they are at least the consolidated democracies so we can leave them alone for now. What about Russia? It was hit really hard by the global economic crisis. Btw, what is happening to Russia's ginormous stabilization fund?

January 23, 2010

The Economist Covers Ukraine…

The Economist covered Ukraine's presidential election in couple recent issues. But this week's print edition has TWO articles about Ukraine, including an article in the Leaders section: An Orange and Two Lemons and Five Years on in Kiev. My first reaction is that someone rushed to write these articles. I've found at least ten points which were overlooked. I don't want even to mention that the map of Ukraine has a weird format so that some provinces have Russian spelling while others have Ukrainian spelling. I hope that whoever wrote those articles knows that Ukrainian is the official language in Ukraine as much as Russian is the official language in Russia.

I want to hear your opinions about these articles. How many mistakes will you find?

January 14, 2010

Assorted Links: 2010 Ukraine’s Presidential Election

  1. Ukraine's Presidential Election goes Twitter! If you are really interested in following Ukraine's Presidential Elections on Twitter, here is a site: http://www.electua.org/. However, I should warn you that most twits are in either Russian or Ukrainian.
  2. The Jamestown Foundation Blog has a very interesting post about the supposedly rising popularity of the technical presidential candidate, Mr. Tihipko. Tammy Lynch asks the following question: "Can Tihipko Spoil Tymoshenko's First-Round Party?". My answer is "NO" unless all reputable public opinion surveys had a really awful margin of error.
  3. Wikipedia has a page devoted to the 2010 Ukraine's Presidential Election. This page has a nice summary table that demonstrates a change in public support of main presidential candidates. Btw, I've never heard about the Research and Branding Group before. Have you? But it seems to be a very popular research organization in this particular table.


     

January 6, 2010

Orange Forever!

I've received a letter from Bishop Paul Peter Jesep, U.S. Spokesperson for His Beatitude Metropolitan Myfodii of Kyiv and All Ukraine, from Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church Kyiv-Patriarchate. With his permission, I post it here. It's a very interesting reflection on political beliefs in the American-Ukrainian community:

"Ukraine's Orange Revolution lives! The country's cultural and spiritual reawakening shows that requiems and obituaries are premature. President Viktor Yushchenko has been criticized for his political and economic stewardship. Some of it justified. Although not yet recognized, his legacy is positive and significant. He is the first Ukrainian president who embraced and encouraged the country's distinct Eastern Slav consciousness. Yushchenko challenged his countrymen, Jew, Muslim, Christian, and non-believer to ask who they were as one Ukrainian nation. He reached out to Jews and Muslims as no leader has before to underscore their contributions to Ukraine. Ultimately, a country's soul is defined by its artists, writers, composers, and the language its people speak. Although unable to show a deft touch in educating those who identified with Russian culture in eastern Ukraine or the Crimea, Yushchenko nurtured a national reawakening. He did so, in part, at the expense of bread and butter issues during a worldwide recession.


 

Yushchenko showed no sympathy in dealing with Russia's national identity crisis. What does it mean to be Russian without Kyiv, the Mother of All Russian cities? His indifference fueled Moscow's ongoing efforts to marginalize Ukrainian culture, language, and history in the international media. According to Russian President Vladimir Putin, Ukraine is nothing more than a breakaway province. He incorrectly insists that it never existed as a nation prior to the breakup of the Soviet Union. Ukraine has a thousand year history. Its final incorporation into Russia occurred when Empress Catherine finally defeated the libertarian, free-spirited Ukrainian kozak state with its rudimentary democratic structure. Spiritually, there can be no Russia without Kyiv. Culturally, politically, and intellectually Moscow cannot let go of Ukraine because to do so leaves its own national identity in question. The Eastern Slavic soul beats in Kyiv, not Moscow, Novgorod, St. Petersburg, or anywhere else in Russia or Belorussia.


 

It's ironic that Viktor Yanukovych, the Moscow supported presidential candidate from eastern Ukraine, recently told the Associated Press that "the development of . . . democratic principle in our country" was a "price . . . too great." Yet Yanukovych benefits from the very freedom he criticizes in his campaign. During the Associated Press interview Yanukovych also mocked the Ukrainian language as "gibberish" and the messiness of democracy as a "variety show." He vows commitment to a Leninist "rule of law" and the restoration of the Russian language to its superior place.


 

Regardless of who is the country's president, the sky is blue if Ukrainians in the country and those in the Diaspora work to cultivate the Ukrainian language. If young artists, writers, dancers, musicians, composers, and Christian and non-Christian spiritual leaders in Ukraine nurture the Ukrainian-Eastern Slav soul then the wheat fields are golden. President Yushchenko opened the door. Complacency will shut it. The Orange Revolution is not about personalities. It is about ideas, values, and principles. It's about the culture of a people. Ukrainians are the only Eastern Slav people with the courage to wrestle with the challenges of democracy. Democracy is not about convenience. It is about liberty.


 

The Orange Revolution can and will live on so long as patriots and those in the Diaspora recognize the critical importance of promoting Ukrainian art, culture, language, and literature. It will not matter who is president so long as ordinary Ukrainians in Ukraine and the Diaspora work to nurture, preserve, and further the country's distinct heritage."

December 17, 2009

Ukraine’s Government Begs the IMF for Help

The IMF gave Ukraine $16.4 billion in the beginning of 2009. But Ukraine got only $11 billion before the IMF got fed up with a political mess in the Ukrainian parliament and government spending unleashed by the Tymoshenko government. President Yushchenko made things worse when he sent the Minimum Wage Bill to the floor of Ukraine's parliament. However, Ukraine's president can only propose a bill while its destiny solely depends on a will of a whimsy parliament. Of course, the minimum wage bill got stock in the parliament because the Tymoshenko government directed all its attention to fighting the phantom outbreak of swine flu in Ukraine. Now we all know what kind of outbreak it was (see previous posts).

This week the Tymoshenko government sent its representatives, including two Deputy Ministers of Finance, Ihor Umanskiy and Anatoliy Myarkovsiy, to the IMF in Washington, D.C., USA. Now Ukraine's government asks just for two billion dollars from the rest of the frozen IMF loan. I have a very obvious question: What for? The government received $11 billion earlier this year and where did it go? Ukraine's president Viktor Yushchenko asks prime-minister Yulia Tymoshenko the same question. The Ukrainian economy still experiences the deepest recession among other FSU countries. What's going on with the government accountability in Ukraine? In the meantime, a date of the first round of the 2010 Presidential election is approaching.

 

December 7, 2009

Assorted Links: Ukraine’s Phantom Outbreak of Swine Flu

Ukraine's short history of political campaigns has seen a lot. But political and economic events surrounding a phantom outbreak of swine flu shocked not only Ukrainians but also the rest of the world.

A free-lance journalist Julia Ioffe has an excellent piece in the Foreign Policy with a great quote from Taras Berezovets, a senior campaign adviser for Ukraine's prime-minister Yulia Tymoshenko:

"We had to create a phantom and then have a white knight riding in to save the day," Taras Berezovets, a senior campaign advisor for Tymoshenko's BYuT bloc, told me (Julia Ioffe) in a Kiev restaurant, confirming widespread suspicions among Ukrainian journalists. According to a campaign adviser to Yulia Tymoshenko, the Ukrainian prime minister who is also a presidential candidate purposely inflated fears of an ongoing swine-flu epidemic to aid her presidential run."

The Washington Post's Philip Pan has another great article about idiocracy surrounding H1N1 outbreak in Ukraine.

Finally, the Slate's Anne Applebaum discusses a chain of events emerged in a response to Ukraine's panicking about the phantom outbreak of swine flu.

November 19, 2009

Assorted Links

KyivPost has a very interesting article about who stands behind the major Ukrainian politicians in the upcoming presidential elections:

A lot of money gets raised, made and spent during elections. In Ukraine, with an election law that does not cap spending by candidates, major campaigns are expected to cost from $60-$70 million in the case of former Verkhovna Rada speaker Arseniy Yatseniuk and up to $100-$150 million or more for the two front-runners, ex-prime minister Victor Yanukovych and Yulia Tymoshenko, Ukraine's current premier.

November 12, 2009

Swine Flu Infects Ukraine’s Politics

It's been in the news since last week that Ukraine has an outbreak of swine flu aka H1N1. Russia, Poland and other neighboring countries overreacted by limiting entrance of Ukrainians across borders. Ukrainian politicians overreacted even more than their foreign peers. Whether the outbreak of swine flu had place, the whole governance system simply folded under exigent circumstances as a house of cards touched by a slight breeze. Politicians did everything what they should not do. Instead of protecting its citizens, the Ukrainian government spread panic and fear among the public.

From UkraineWatch

First, it is very interesting that the government was solely responsible for a panic among the public. The Ukrainian government misinformed citizens about H1N1 outbreak. The World Health Organization says that there was no outbreak of swine flu in Ukraine. The government spread a panic among population when Prime Minister Tymoshenko and the Health Minister announced that Ukraine's Ministry of Health registered a record number of people infected with swine flu somewhere in Western Ukraine. However, the World Health Organization has not confirmed an outbreak of swine flu in Ukraine yet! Moreover, a number of deaths from pneumonia that is a complication of seasonal flu was very far from a critical level. Since "the outbreak of H1N1 flu" (October 29, 2009) Ukraine that is a nation with 46 million people has lost 213 people from pneumonia. Only six cases of the H1N1 infection were confirmed. Several medical doctors have already criticized the Tymoshenko government for misinterpreting data and misinforming the public. The most adamant critic of the government incompetence is Dr. Komarovsky who went on several TV shows to calm down Ukrainians and dissolve a myth about the H1N1 outbreak. The government has already changed its position on the epidemic H1N1 situation by announcing that its preventive measures have already reduced the number of flue infections at least by a factor of four.

Second, instead of H1N1 outbreak, we witnessed, perhaps, a final break in the Orange coalition. When Ukraine's president Yushchenko rushed to ask for medical supplies from Europe in order to fight the nonexistent epidemic swine flu, Ukraine's prime minister Tymoshenko ridiculed him for relying on foreign aid instead of doing something himself. Mrs. Tymoshenko promised Ukrainians that she would provide masks for free at each mobile office of her party across country. President Yushchenko retaliated by filing a law suit to the Supreme Court against the Tymoshenko government for failing to report data on a spread of seasonal flu and holding public rallies during "the outbreak of H1N1 virus".

Third, Mrs. Tymoshenko blatantly used "a fight with swine flu" for the sake of her presidential campaign. She proclaimed a fight with swine flu "the second great trial given by the world to Ukraine after the world financial crisis". She made it clear that H1N1 "outbreak" is her number 1 priority in the ongoing presidential campaign. Mrs. Tymoshenko went to war with the swine flu with such zeal and vigor as Miguel de Cervantes' heroic knight Don Quixote who rode his horse to fight windmills. I guess the WHO officials were really touched by the brave heart of Mrs. Tymoshenko that they reconsidered the status of H1N1 in Ukraine to "assumed outbreak". WOW! Well, it's hard to blame the WHO for still being shy when only six person died with a confirmed H1N1 virus from 250,000 "assumed" infected in a country with 46 million people. I am not a doctor, but it doesn't even look to me as a potential outbreak.

Why and what happened to Ukraine's government? I don't really know. But "H1N1 outbreak" shows once again a "professionalism" of Ukrainian politicians. The "outbreak" also demonstrates that what government can do when it is a group of incompetent self-interested individuals delegated with executive and legislative power and driven by the electoral campaign. This kind of government can't do anything good!

November 10, 2009

Swine Flu Causes Outbreak of Political Stupidity in Ukraine

Dr. Yevhen Komarovsky, M.D., has an excellent OP-ED in Ukraine's leading English language newspaper Kyiv Post. Dr. Komarovksy not only refutes a myth about H1N1 outbreak in Ukraine but also ridicules a political incompetence of the Ukrainian government.

Here is an example of how efficient is a centralized system of governance in Ukraine:

"I recently talked to a nurse working in a public hospital. She received a call from a chief of medicine, who said: "Tomorrow you have to bring three face masks to your work." Her justified objection that they're difficult to come by was met by the boss' curt reply: "It's your problem. The night is long. There's enough time to sew them."

November 2, 2009

Russia’s Gas and Ukraine’s Political Mess

Russia's Prime Minister Vladimir Putin typically rushed to accuse Ukraine of failing to make monthly payments for Russian gas. Mr. Putin even suggested EU to lend Ukraine at least $1 billion to help it pay for gas supplies.

BusinessWeek's Lynn Berry quotes Mr. Putin:

"Let the Europeans throw in a lousy billion," he said in televised remarks after talks with Danish Prime Minister Lars Lokke Rasmussen.

"Why have they gotten so stingy down there? Let them get something out of their pockets," he said, in typically colorful language. "They have money, too."

Lynn Berry also writes that Putin first raised the gas payment alarm last Friday, when he said that Ukrainian Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko had warned him that Ukraine's president, Viktor Yushchenko, was making it difficult to pay the gas bill. Once again Mr. Putin can't help himself to stay neutral when it comes to the Ukrainian politics. Btw, Mrs. Tymoshenko whose government runs the state-owned natural gas company NAFTOGAZ is responsible for Russian gas import and payment. President Yushchenko has nothing to do with this. However, the upcoming presidential elections create more benefits from any black PR. Did I mention that the Tymoshenko government bans to use black PR against prime minister?

October 22, 2009

Ukraine’s Gambling Industry Goes Online

Ukraine's Prime Minister Tymoshenko has already built a reputation of anti-market politician. Few Ukrainians were surprised when the Gambling Bill introduced by the Tymoshenko government went into effect last month. In brief, this bill outlaws operations of gambling industry within metropolitan areas except in the specially designated zones for gambling. The gambling zones will be established in suburbs farthest from the downtown. It's not clear how the government will regulate a size of the gambling zones. Will all gambling business be able to fit in these still-to-be-built zones? Neither anybody knows whether owners of casinos will be compensated for business liquidation and relocation. By the way, who is going to build the gambling zones? There are too many unknown variables in this equation.

Why would you do it at all when Ukraine's economy is going through a deep recession? Don't you need to support business instead of shutting it down? What about other jobs which are related to the gambling industry? Btw, the gambling business generates more than 30% of local tax revenues in Ukraine. For instance, tax revenues from the gambling business made up 60% of a city's budget in Kharkiv, the second largest city of Ukraine. However, Mrs. Tymoshenko proudly uses the Gambling Bill in her presidential campaign. One of her campaign ads says: "Gambling Business is Outlawed: She (Mrs. Tymoshenko) Works!"

But Ukrainian entrepreneurs strike back! The owners of gambling business found a way to keep their operations at the old establishments. The entrepreneurs swapped casino's license for internet café's license. The former casinos became the internet cafés. Brand new desktops with internet access replaced slot machines and poker tables. Now the former card dealers introduce themselves as IT consultants. Btw, you can still buy buzz there. So how does it work? It's simple. You just play the same games online. Instead of buying chips, you deposit $100 to your internet-based account and then play black jack, throw a dice and so on. The owners of "internet cafes" say that after all they benefited from the Gambling Bill because they found ways to cut down their costs. One, internet café license is cheaper than the gambling license. Two, Ukraine's Tax Administration classifies internet café as a sole proprietorship for tax purposes so that the entrepreneurs just pay a flat income tax of 300 hryvnia ($40) regardless of their total revenues. Three, they also cut down on their labor cost because the internet café needs much fewer workers than a small-scale casino. Overall, the Gambling Bill is a really bad idea. It definitely hurts a gambling business that is one of the major sources of tax revenues in Ukraine. So far the effect of the government regulation was partially cancelled out by emergent entrepreneurial response. Let's hope that the internet café business is not the next on the Tymoshenko list.

From UkraineWatch

October 18, 2009

It’s a Final Countdown

For the fourth time in its history, Ukraine will have the presidential election. It will be less than in 90 days. The main competition will be between both pro-Russian politicians: prime-minister Tymoshenko and POR's front-runner Yanukovich. The Central Election Committee of Ukraine estimates that the government will have to spend at least $160 million on the elections. A registration fee for each presidential candidate is $314k.

According to the most recent public opinion poll SOCIS, the most popular presidential candidates are 59-yo Viktor Yanukovich (28.7%), 48-yo Yulia Tymoshenko (19%), and 35-yo Arsenyi Yatseniuk (8%). Ukraine's president Viktor Yushchenko enjoys only half of public support of another Orange Revolutionary, Yulia Tymoshenko. In terms of political ideology, Mrs. Tymoshenko represents the left-wing of Ukrainian politics, while Mr. Yanukovich poses himself as the right-wing and Mr. Yatseniuk is in the center. If we use analogy with the American politics, Ukraine's prime-minister is a socialist democrat where Mr. Yanukovich is a republican and Mr. Yatseniuk is independent.